Australia's digital duty of care: can your dating app prove its moderation checks?

Published 16 November 20267 min readBy Pleenk Approve

Your trust and safety team does good work. Every day, it removes fake profiles, handles reports and bans scammers. But imagine a regulator writes to you tomorrow: "Send us your risk assessment and proof that your measures work. You have 30 days." What could you send?

In Australia, this question is about to become very real. The government wants to impose a "digital duty of care" on online services. The idea: a service can no longer just react to complaints. It must spot in advance the risks its product creates, reduce them, and prove it.

The short answer: if your dating app has members in Australia, get ready to document three things. Which risks have you identified? What measures have you taken? How do you know they work, for example that banned members do not come back? The bill has not passed yet, but the timetable is getting tighter.

Where does the bill stand?

The bill is called the Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026. It amends Australia's online safety law. Communications Minister Anika Wells introduced it in the House of Representatives on 15 October 2026. The House passed it on 28 October.

The bill is now before the Senate. A Senate committee must report by 20 November 2026 at the latest. The government wants the bill passed before the end of the year. However, the opposition has said it will vote against it in the Senate.

If the bill passes, the duty of care will apply one year after it becomes law. It will then replace the industry codes currently overseen by the eSafety Commissioner, Australia's online safety regulator. Those codes keep applying during the transition.

What would the duty of care change for a platform?

The bill covers a wide range of online services: social media, hosting services, search engines, app stores and AI tools. The draft published in September also listed services that let users communicate with each other. The bill does not name dating apps. But an app where members create a profile and message each other is likely to be covered. Have your lawyer confirm this point.

According to the law firm Pinsent Masons, the standard is changing. Measures will have to be "appropriate and effective", and cost will not be an excuse to do less. The main obligations are:

  • Assess risks. In the September draft, the assessment had to be done at least once a year. It also had to be repeated before any change to the service that could add risk.
  • Keep records. The same draft required these assessments to be kept for at least six years. The regulator could ask to receive them within 30 days.
  • Publish figures. The regulator could require data on complaints, moderation and the number of Australian accounts suspended or removed, with the reasons.
  • Give users tools. For example, the option to opt out of automated content recommendations.

The penalties are heavy. A company could be fined up to 109.2 million Australian dollars, or more than €60 million.

On 12 November, the news site MediaNama reported on the eSafety Commissioner's submission to the Senate. The regulator is asking for an extra power: to require a new risk assessment. It also wants an independent audit, paid for by the service itself. In other words, a third party could review your evidence.

Why are dating apps on the front line?

The dating sector already knows these expectations in Australia. Since 1 October 2024, an online dating industry code has applied to its signatories. The code is voluntary. Its signatories include Match Group (Tinder), Bumble and Grindr. Strict enforcement began on 1 April 2025.

The code already asks signatory apps to:

  • detect dangerous behaviour and act against members who break safety rules;
  • close a member's account, where needed, across all of the company's services;
  • offer reporting tools that are visible and easy to use;
  • publish transparency reports, including the number of Australian accounts closed.

An independent committee oversees the code. It can issue a warning or remove an app from the code, but it cannot impose fines. The duty of care would change this logic. The law would apply to every covered service, signatory or not, with fines at stake.

For a dating app, the foreseeable risks are well known: fake profiles, romance scams, harassment and banned members coming back. The regulator will not only ask whether you have a policy. It will ask whether that policy works.

What does solid evidence of your checks look like?

A written policy is not enough. A regulator, an auditor or your PSP (the payment service provider that processes your card payments) wants dated facts. Here are the questions we would ask, and the evidence that answers them.

Who is really behind the profile? If you show a "verified profile" badge, it must rest on real verification. A simple selfie proves little against a deepfake. A liveness check confirms that a real person is in front of the camera, not a photo or a video. What you need to show: how many profiles are verified, when, and with which method.

Are your moderation decisions recorded? For each suspension or ban, record the reason, the date, who decided and the evidence used. If the regulator asks for the number of closed accounts and their reasons, you will already have it. This work also helps in Europe. The DSA, the EU Digital Services Act, already requires you to explain a suspension to the member concerned (Article 17).

Do your banned members come back? This is the awkward question. A ban tied to an email address or a phone number can be bypassed in ten minutes. If a banned scammer returns under another profile, your measure is not "effective" in the sense of the bill. A ban tied to the person's verified identity holds much better. Also measure how often banned members come back. An auditor will understand that figure at once.

Could you send everything within 30 days? If your evidence is spread across three tools and two teams, 30 days go by fast. Do a dry run: gather your risk assessment, your moderation figures and your bans from the last quarter. Time how long it takes.

One word of caution: verifying more identities does not mean storing more ID documents. The more you keep, the more a data breach would cost you. Keep proof of the check, not the document.

What we would do if we ran a dating app open to Australia

  • Write a first risk assessment now. Fake profiles, scams, harassment, banned members returning: for each risk, note its likelihood, its severity and the measure taken.
  • Appoint an owner. One person signs the assessment. They update it before each new feature, such as video or group chat.
  • Tie bans to identity, not to accounts. Start with bans for fraud, which cost your members the most.
  • Make your "verified" badge honest. It should rest on identity verification with a liveness check. It should also state clearly what it guarantees.
  • Prepare your transparency figures. Closed accounts, reasons, time taken to handle reports: produce them every quarter, even if nobody asks yet.
  • Follow the Senate. The 20 November report may change the bill. Do not freeze your procedures before the final version, but start collecting evidence.

In the United States, a recent law already requires dating sites to warn members who were contacted by an account banned for fraud. We cover it in our article on the Romance Scam Prevention Act. Both laws point the same way: bans that hold, and decisions you can prove.

How Pleenk Approve can help

At the heart of Pleenk Approve is a single digital identity. Every member you choose to verify goes through a liveness check. Pleenk encrypts their identity and stores it in a single wallet: your platform receives proof, never the ID document. All of their accounts and any bans are linked to that wallet. A banned member therefore cannot simply come back under another profile. Your moderation stays yours: Pleenk connects to your AI moderation tool and keeps proof of the checks carried out. From Pleenk, you generate your report automatically and share it with your PSP in one click. You then have consistent evidence to show a regulator. Is your dating app open in Australia or elsewhere, and do you want to review your evidence? Write to us at contact@pleenk.com.


This article is for information only and does not constitute legal advice. The Australian bill may still change in the Senate. Have your analysis checked by your lawyer.

Sources

More articles